Showing posts with label economy. Show all posts
Showing posts with label economy. Show all posts

Tuesday, February 17, 2009

Quality In the Face of Challenges


Recently there has been a great deal of talk about the economy. It is on everyone's minds as daily we hear a constant drumbeat of bad news. More jobs lost, the "market" down, this or that company looking for a bailout.

The Out-of-School Time field has not been immune. Many programs are worried about summer enrollment, private and government dollars, and the use of a constant or diminished number of resources becoming ever more contested by programs and organizations - many of which are currently burning through 2009 reserves prior to the 2010 fiscal year meltdown. This is a time when the cohesion of the field is being challenged as many program managers and directors are in open competition with their peers. Applications to every source of funding, no matter how small, are up. While this may lead to many fractures - often between people who have known one another or worked together for years - these economic conditions make it more important for the Out-of-School Time field to come together and settle on an identity and key areas of quality. Managers and organization leaders must also be frank about financing, funding, and how supporting each other can help sustain yourself.

Over the past several years there have been various large system-building or capacity-building initiatives. These initiatives have taken much energy and often funding away from the work at the ground. Considering where the economy is, large-scale system-building initiatives may have to be reviewed for what is useful - and what of these endeavors are boondoggles that can no longer be supported with private or public funds. Leaders in the field may have to reflect on what their practices and expectations have been and use this period to bring these in to line with our current realities. What are we asking of the direct service staff? What training are we providing them? What is the actual scope of the work and can we continue to measure Out-of-School program quality against individual child in-school performance?

Programs may need to openly discuss what it means to share resources. We hear a great deal about "share resources" but what does that mean?
Share staff (some programs have been doing this)?
Share costs for materials?
Share space (many programs have be doing this)?
Share program participants?
Write grants together?
Merge management and close some organizations?

The last item is perhaps the most sticky of the points. Sharing of craft sticks or direct-service staff always is more popular than closing down upper management and even consolidating the infrastructure of organizations that provide similar services. It begs the sticky question of who is taking over whom?

The market conditions have not been favorable even in times of plenty (or at least the past eight years by comparison to today) to smaller programs or individual actions by managers to adapt their program in the face of NCLB-style initiatives and educational and enrichment misadventures. Certainly there have been many more barriers to entry placed in the way by creeping and pervasive "professionalization" that has provided no back end infrastructure of consistent funding, agreed upon standards of quality, or a sold commitment to either placing Out-of-School Time within the area of Youth Development or adjunct to academic remediation. Gone are the days when an interested community member could launch a needed program for idle children around her. With start-up times, organizational bureaucracy and funding restrictions such as restricted or project-driven funds, many of these elementary-age children may be adults before the program gets off the ground. Can a field that has slowed down in innovation respond to economic challenges in a timely manner?

Much of our current situation did not arise all at once but came from years of unsuitable development and unsustainable investments. Despite the many conferences and committees, the field appears at a social level (colleague to colleague) to be more fractured than united. This is indeed a larger symptom of the problems in how funding was deployed. The amount of unrestricted funding has diminished or vanished, inspiring many programs to higher levels of activities often outside of their traditional keen. The inconsistent "investment" by private and public entities and individuals that created programs at whim and abandoned them inexplicably.

What may be needed now is for more members of the field to come together and a renewal in that spirit that launched the Out-of-School Time field in the first place. Individuals inspired by the idea that children and youth can benefit from an expanded number of developmental settings and that those settings are intentional and provide the context for the learning that occurs in formal settings and does not extend nor replace that formal system. Out-of-School Time is more than challenged by current market forces and that once over, business can resume as usual.

The field of Out-of-School Time faces a critical juncture. We must look at the old ways of thinking and shed them. We must brush aside our differences in philosophy and approach and look to the fundamentals of the work and then advocate methodically for consistent funding for the kind of work this field was meant for, not the sort of work we are often given or demanded of us. Increasingly on the ground there is a frustration in the way things are done. Change happens only when we are the first ones to make it in ourselves. Time will tell what direction each one of us chooses.

Thursday, February 5, 2009

Out-of-School Goes to the State House


Today was Advocacy Day for Out-of-School time programs up at the State House on Beacon Hill. This event brought together a diverse audience of many different programs and workers of many different ages and walks of life. The event was organized by Massachusetts Afterschool Partnership had speakers from government, programs, and youth voices.

The room was full of many professionals in the field of Out-of-School Time and one thing was certain from several of the conversations in the room - advocacy was not a single day event this year but will involve hard work and determination over the next few months to make sure that funding is either preserved or that lawmakers and the public see that often social programs need more government funding when times are tough not less.

Program coordinators are reporting an increase in the need for assistance to families who cannot pay fees they were used to paying just a year ago. Summer attendance of fee-for-service programs have also dropped last year and there seems to be worry that this year will see a substantial drop off in enrollment. One coordinator said that she posted a part time position at her program on craigslist and rather than a one-day bump in resumes, she has received about 25 per day for the past week and a half - many from people who claim they are looking for work because their program was closed or position eliminated. What was more shocking was that many of these resumes were coming from other locations in the state, and region.

These are hard times indeed, if these reports reflect the reality out there. Representative St. Fleur when she spoke said that she sees our glass as half-full. She said that attorneys are only as good as the last case they've won and that each year the field of Out-of-School Time must again "win" funding. This may indeed be the case. One person in the OST field joked that anyone who claims they know what to do in these financial times is either fooling themselves or others or both.

One good thing about Out-of-School programs is that they have already learned to operate with little funding and do extraordinary things using few resources. Staff are usually part time. Technology is kept to a minimum. It may be that the funding needed to continue these programs is actually small amount considering the overall state budget or the costs of operating other educational services, such as the Boston Public Schools or flat funding certain line items over others. Glue, craft sticks, some creative energy from staff have already provide numerous youth development opportunities. It may be that our ask is not that much. After all, give even 1/100th or 1/1000th of 900 billion dollars (the current number for the stimulus plan) and our field can change the lives of young people and give children places to play and learn.

Tuesday, September 2, 2008

Uncertainty in Back to School Ritual


Rather than Labor Day, "back to school" sales mark the unofficial end of summer. The two lazy weeks of August are spent with stores pulling out the unsold flip-flops and towels and filling them with child-friendly office supplies, organizers, and sundry trinkets of learning. College age people disappear from the general population, from keeping watch at cash registers and serving at local restaurants and amass at designated "college towns" where they won't be seen until next summer. Teachers vanish into their rooms with cans of paint and their own brushes if in poor neighborhoods to renovate their classrooms and to stock shelves with new book orders in well to do areas. After-School also is ready - that is, scrambling to see if the vouchers are approved, the space permit asked for in June has been signed, whether there is staff, if the staff hired two weeks ago will show up to work on the first day or "call in" and handle a full mail bin whether paper or electronic.

Add to this ritual, the new uncertainty. There are many crises in the world, and rather than these being far-off conflicts, famines, and troubles, these worries from a world away are all very close to home in our newspapers, on television, and across the internet. The economy is foremost in the minds of many Americans as they send their children to school. A mother mused to me over the long weekend, "We thought we knew what kind of world Fay was born into. But that world of thirteen months ago is gone and we're not sure what it has been replaced with."

The gloom-and-doom crowd are latching on to this uncertainty and compiling long lists of the erosion of rights as well as touting an end of the middle class. They point to bus routes canceled, further cut back on activities - but this time to pay for heating and lights rather than lowering taxes, and more students in greater debt for higher education. In some areas, this uncertainty is not new. In some areas the lack of resources didn't need an economy in recession - the gap was already there.

After School has always worked with little money, few resources, and an often pushed aside agenda of youth development when many districts see this time as a further addition to the school day of 21st century tests and necessary preparation for those tests. Like Chicago, where years of inequality is coming to a head, or New York City where year after year the state did not provide those schools with the funding they were due, Boston perhaps will also see in these uncertain times a good opportunity to examine the quality of resources for all children and see that while some children are having to do more with less now, many children have always lived in that uncertainty.

After School programs may find it harder to survive in the coming months. They may, however, be the programs that can be an example to others as to how to make the most out of the least. Like many people, we may have to just wait a few months and see.

BOSTnet Network

Disclaimer

BOSTnet is an unofficial site operated as a beta of a larger project. This site is intended to stimulate discussion and on-line interest in Out-of-School Time including hosting opposing views. Comments, content, links and news whether originating from persons identified at "BOSTnet," posted by or linking to independent authors, or commentators affiliated or unaffiliated with BOSTnet not do not reflect the opinions, positions, or thoughts of Build the Out-of-School Time Network (BOSTnet), its board members, supporters, or those communities where it operates.